I registered just now to comment on how disappointed I am in the last 2 pages of this thread.

There's hardly any talk about Prophet of Kruphix at all

That happens. It's because no one really has anything new to add, so the conversations starts to drift.

Let's face it this post was pretty much 35 pages of nothing new.

I made this account, confirmed the email, and posted here, while my opponent played during my upkeep. Prophet of Kruphix is great....

Yep. I do hope it gets the axe but it looks like "No Changes" is the new normal. That's not entirely a bad thing as it allows us to just keep playing our decks, but it would be nice to have an occasional shake-up or ban down the road. We'll see though.

Unban shake-ups are much nicer then ban shakeups. Every aspect of PoK has pretty much been covered in this thread, I really hope it stays.

MTGS is pretty PoKed out as well. By now the RC has all the ammo they need to stay well informed on her.

Joz is finally happy.

But i am really going to miss Prophet, even though it's for the best

I'm wondering if he'll return anytime soon now that his wish has been fulfilled.

He may have died for our sins, but in the end he saved us...

Actually just checked his blog. He mentioned the ban on his latest post, but it was literally just that. Maybe this was so big he felt he could not add to perfection lol.

My happiness level has died down somewhat but I'm still ecstatic. Stupid card is gone, Momir is slightly more manageable now. Good work all around.

Given that he abandoned this site for more or less the dumbest reason imaginable (which had nothing to do with PoK)... I doubt it, but we'll see.

I can imagine the internal debate over banning Prophet. On the one hand, it was a powerful, centralizing creature with green in its casting cost. All the blue decks loved it. History has shown that won't be tolerated. Centralizing green cards just can't be. On the other hand, it was a game changing blue value engine, and like Deadeye Navigator and Teferi, history has shown them to be immune from the bans. Broken is part of blue's color pie, after all. Here we have a card that is both simultaneously.

I'm still trying to understand when Prophet become that broken that it gets banned?

I would like to thank the Admin of MTGcommander.net for ruining commander for our play group. Banning Prophet of Kruphix now allows for the control player who play Sen Triplets and Memnarch to freely go about stealing our cards and playing them against us more easily, I really don't think you thought about these rule changes.

NOT EVERYONE LIKES TO PLAY CONTROL!!!!!

Which is why it's good that Prophet is banned. Untapped mana on every turn is a control player's dream.